On warreveals that clausewitz used the centerofgravity metaphor. A clausewitzian approach strategic studies quarterly spring 2017 103 breakeven point for hostilities, leading to a newly accepted balance of interests between contending parties. It is the source of operational plans intended to convert nominal military capability into useful performance against the enemy. The block surveys concepts of international relations. A very capable response to phillip meilingers busting the icon. Containment very much fits in with clausewitzs idea of the limited objective, and crush. Where clausewitz discusses purpose and means or war plans, his intention is clearly prescriptive and represents an ideal strategic construct whereby all parts gel seamlessly into a rationally directed whole. The jolles translation is owned by random house, though it was done for military strachan, clausewitzs on war. Of all the classic studies on war, the art of war by sun tzu and on war by clausewitz are still the most outstanding, modern, and relevant despite the passage of time. Michael howard and peter paret, commentary bernard brodie, princeton university press, princeton, 1984. Clausewitz and strategic studies case study template. This book sheds light on clausewitzs purpose in writing on war, and the methodology he employed. United states army war college department of national security and strategy.
This book lays out clausewitzs purpose and methodology in a brisk and straightforward style. The logic of conventional deterrence if the romantic prussian philosopher crossed paths with trainer angelo dundee, he would extol the virtues of counterpunching in boxing as well as in war. Nitze school of advanced international studies sais. Clausewitz and contemporary war oxford scholarship. The student of international relations seeks from clausewitz not a theory of. Wallach as most would suspect when studying clausewitz is looking to establish relations between the military and politics. Does the us army in multidomain operations 2028 lack a clear theory of victory.
Although the study of war and strategy would often go hand in hand with military history, from very early times there have appeared treatises on strategy actually on the art of war that are. The gap between sun tzus the art of war 3rd or 4th century b. The study of new practices of security following the cold war are seldom linked to the discussion on rma. Politicalmilitary and strategictactical military theory throughout on war, clausewitz argued firmly for a dialectical view. Clausewitz, suntzu and thucydides 75 what strategy does strategy provides a theory of success.
Historical approaches to securitystrategic studies. Restoring balance to the influence of clausewitz, strategic studies quarterly fall, 2007, pp. Impact of clausewitzs theories on first world war essay. It has been translated into english several times as on war. Clausewitzs original definition follows the physics analogy more closely than previous analyses of his work have appreciated. Strategic studies quarterly winter 2018 9 clausewitz as counterpuncher. His most notable work, vom kriege on war, was unfinished at his death. Clausewitzs insights into the decreasing relevance of history as a. It discusses clausewitz theory on war, and try to explore if it is still relevant to the new wars like what so called the war on. In addition to the various concepts behind the war, clausewitz theories of war have come under increased scrutiny with. He is also a visiting scholar at the philip merrill center for strategic studies at the johns hopkins universitys paul h.
Clausewitz was a realist in many different senses and, while in. A reader brings together key essays on strategic theory by some of the leading contributors to the field. Clausewitzs center of gravity its not what we thought lieutenant colonel antulio j. War plans cover every war is a tool that policy uses to.
Criticism of clausewitz theory of war, however, has been built upon two false presuppositions. Bellinger, professor of clausewitz studies, army war college, bliss hall, 30 aug. The enduring relevance of clausewitzs on war air university. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading clausewitz. His unfinished work, together with his historical studies, was posthumously. Stoker does a good job in relating the frustrations clausewitz experienced as a staff officer with the russogerman legion. Both are based on a fundamental misreading of clausewitz on war. Pdf this paper reexamines the theoretical underpinnings of strategic studies, proposing a novel theory and a new framework for analysing.
War is regarded by military experts even today as the definitive study. Strategic studies essay choose a pre20th century military strategist and show howwhy their ideas remain relevant in the 21st century. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. This perspective is most clear in book 8 where clausewitz states. Clausewitzs categories of war and the supersession of. Strategic studies institute ssi us army war college. Based on a detailed reading of clausewitz book on war, this paper proposes that clausewitz. A thesis submitted for the degree of phd at the university. Clausewitz and strategic studies research paper 2646 words. With the exception of the collective innovative works on nuclear strategy written primarily in the. Clausewitz was so far mostly interpreted as the paradigmatic thinker of major interstate war.
Certain of his central insights have suffered distorting representations in recent years. Prospect theory and the defence in clausewitzs on war paper. This revised volume contains several new essays and updated introductions to each section. A similar assumption can be made in the study of strategy. He holds a phd in military history and strategic studies from the university of. Clausewitz explained that small wars should be fought to weaken a stronger enemy and increase the chances of winning the large war and achieve its strategic objectives. In the scope of the studies are also subjects such as the role of intelligence, diplomacy, and international. Strategic studies is an interdisciplinary academic field centered on the study of conflict and peace strategies, often devoting special attention to the relationship between international politics, geostrategy, international diplomacy, international economics, and military power. Gatzke stressed clausewitzs unlimited war of annihilation, his absolute. Bacevich, americas war for the greater middle east. Clausewitz is a central figure in both the academic field of strategic studies and the practice of military education worldwide.
On war has become one of the most respected classics on military strategy. The volume comprises hardtofind classics in the field as well as the latest scholarship. In the 1820s, however, his study of history led him to acknowledge. Levy chair of economic geography and national security at the us naval war college. This is an essay which has been submitted as requirement for the international security course. There are good biographies of clausewitz in existence, and his life and times are subject of fascinating study by military historians, but. Nonetheless, clausewitzs own purposes were practical and his approach to strategic analysis has 4 on war, hp p. Clausewitz and international politics volume 16 issue 1 hugh. Clausewitz and world war i the role of various theories and concepts in the first world war has been an issue of considerable concern that has attracted various studies in attempts to understand their influence in the various battles related to the war. Co lin gray, clausewit z, history, and the future strategic world, prepared fo r the strategic and co mba t studies institute conference past futures.
Nardulli, clausewitz and the reorientation of nuclear strategy, journal of strategic studies, december 1982, 494510. Clausewitz enlisted in the prussian army in 1792, and in 179395 he took part and was commissioned in the campaigns of the first. In this vein, one may well regard works like those of thucydides and clausewitz as belonging to the broad field of strategicsecurity studies. Pdf clausewitz on small war download read online free. A comparative analysis of the development of mdo and the historical concepts of active defense and airland battle reveals the necessity of greater insight into sources of russian and chinese behavior and countering mechanisms, what constitutes effective deterrence, and greater clarity regarding the political will. As theory and as plan strategy explains how victory, or at least advantage, will be achieved. He has been writing on war and his theory since his days in the military academy. While many scholars agree that clausewitzs work is frequently misunderstood, almost none have explored his methodology to see whether it might enhance our understanding of his concepts.
1601 1048 773 1359 176 1075 226 1431 974 1438 1478 840 1413 200 1560 921 1398 1107 959 59 1551 1360 140 369 315 1146 1220 298 1156 82 860 231 1095 356 501 1033 333